at the beginning piggie was pretending to be a frog at the middle gerald was werid that hi whode be a frog at the end piggie prtended to be a frog but gerald did not no wey i likt this book is that gerald was skreming.

the pigin was sprisd that the duckling gets a cookie at the middle the pigin was mad that the duckling got a cookie.at the end the duckling got the cookie for the pigeon why i liket this book is that this book the pigeon was silly.